Wednesday, July 19, 2023

Storyteller by Patricia Reilly Giff

 

Giff, Patricia Reilly. 2010. Storyteller. New York, NY: Wendy Lamb Books. ISBN 9780375838880


Summary


This historical fiction novel alternates between the perspective of two young girls who are related yet living three centuries apart. When her artist father must take a business trip, 21st century Elizabeth is sent to stay with the sister of her late mother, Aunt Libby, who she doesn’t really know. There she finds the portrait of an ancestor named Eliza, known as Zee, who she bears an uncanny resemblance to. Zee was a young farm girl in the 18th century during the outbreak of the Revolutionary War, whose Patriot family is suddenly at odds with Loyalist neighbors. As war threatens to tear apart Zee’s family, we witness the hardships she endures to reconnect with them at Fort Dayton in upstate New York. The girls’ stories alternate, highlighting similarities between their personalities and experiences. As present-day Elizabeth attempts to learn about what happened to Zee, she ends up also forming strong connections to her mother’s family through her Aunt Libby and Cousin Harry. Their eventual discoveries of what happened to Zee give satisfying conclusion to both girls’ stories. Elizabeth finds purpose through her natural talent as a storyteller of Zee’s story of strength and determination.



Critical Analysis


Where Newbery Honor author Patricia Reilly Giff’s book really excels is through the intertwined character development of Elizabeth and Zee. The situations in their lives may be entirely different, but the details and mindset of the girls made the alternating chapters connect, even though their timeframe was three centuries apart. For example, after Elizabeth is worried about disappointing Libby and wondering what to tell her, we see Zee going through that same struggle with what to tell her own mother. After Zee promises herself she will be different and become strong and tough, we see Elizabeth asserting that she is going to change. These kinds of parallels throughout the book unify these two stories, making the transition between them feel natural and intentional. 


Both girls, while well-intentioned, find themselves making mistakes a lot. Their inner conflict with this makes them highly relatable to young readers. Through their perspectives, the reader sees universal themes such as the loss of a parent, the importance of family connections, struggling with feeling useful, and finding inner strength you didn’t know you had.


Giff weaves accurate history of the Revolutionary War into the story through both girl’s perspectives, particularly of the Oriskany battle in New York. The horrors of war are conveyed in a way that is understandable to children. A map of the fort locations with Zee’s journey is in the beginning of the book. An Author’s Note in the back of the book provides more facts about the forts mentioned in the story and an Acknowledgements page identifies some sources the author used for information. Facts about the war are shared in Elizabeth’s story, which is told in third-person present tense, as Elizabeth learns from Cousin Harry. Zee’s first-person past tense chapters allow the reader to feel as though they are seeing history happen through her eyes. Giff’s style changes between the girls, offering more descriptive views of the past from Zee. One time this is done remarkably is when Zee is hiding in a cave with a fever, and her lines become almost verse-like as she moves in and out of consciousness. That sense of wooziness, shock, and discomfort is not easy to describe in words, yet it was written in such a way that the reader feels like they are experiencing it with Zee. 


This story was both heartbreaking and heartwarming, but always full of heart. It gives an inside look into a moment in history that will have readers yearning to learn more. The mystery and eventual discovery of what happened to Zee is extremely satisfying, as is seeing both girls become a stronger, bolder version of themselves. A fantastic historical fiction novel and superb example of storytelling!



Awards & Reviews


Bank Street Child Study Children’s Book Award Nominee

New Hampshire Great Stone Face Children’s Book Master List

New Jersey Garden State Children's Book Awards

New York On Your Mark, Get Set, Read! Summer Reading 

Tennessee Volunteer State Book Awards

Wyoming Indian Paintbrush Book Award


Booklist (September 15, 2010 (Vol. 107, No. 2))

The horror of war is clearly conveyed without graphic specifics, and the historical framework makes this a strong classroom choice. It is the intertwined, personal stories of the two girls, though, that will win hearts, and the characters’ growing maturity and discovery of their strengths will resonate strongly with young readers.


Horn Book Guide (Spring 2011)

Giff alternates accounts about the two girls' lives, weaving historical facts into Zee's tale. The characters' compelling voices drive the story.

Kirkus Reviews (August 15, 2010)

… a lovely story about love and loss, a little-known aspect of Revolutionary history and the way the past informs the present, and the ending is gratifying. 


Publishers Weekly (September 6, 2010)

This novel by two-time Newbery Honor author Giff gracefully bridges two eras and two insightful perspectives. … As she brings these characters and history alive, Giff again demonstrates her own gift for storytelling. 


School Library Journal (November 1, 2010)

Giff juxtaposes two stories to highlight a little-known piece of Revolutionary War history. … The fast-paced narrative, toggling back and forth between the 18th and 21st centuries, will keep readers interested.



Connections  


  • There are many parallels between Elizabeth and Zee. Create a t-chart of examples from each girl’s story of feelings and situations that aligned.

  • Geography Extension: Look up present and historical maps of the area where Zee traveled to get to Fort Dayton and Fort Stanwix. How do they compare? How has the area changed since the 18th century?

  • Both the Patriots and the Loyalists felt very strongly about their cause. Research the reasons both groups felt their side was correct. You could also form two teams to each take on one group and have a debate using the facts found.

  • Different perspectives played a big part in the development of this story. Try writing your own version of this story from the viewpoint of another character in the book, such as Zee’s Loyalist friend Ammy.

  • If you enjoyed this book, you may enjoy these other historical fiction novels by Patricia Reilly Giff as well:

Gingersnap. ISBN 9780440421788

Lily’s Crossing. ISBN 9780440414537

Willow Run. ISBN 9780440238010





No comments:

Post a Comment