Sunday, July 9, 2023

The Extraordinary Mark Twain (According to Susy) by Barbara Kerley and illustrated by Edwin Fotheringham

 A book cover with a person holding a stick

Description automatically generated

Kerley, Barbara. 2010. The Extraordinary Mark Twain (According to Susy). Ill. by Edwin Fotheringham. New York, NY: Scholastic Press. ISBN 9780545125086



Summary


“According to Susy, people were… well, just plain wrong about her papa.”


Mark Twain’s daughter Susy is annoyed that people only see her father as a humorist, when he was actually so much more. She sets out to write her own biography about her famous father to set the record straight. Susy carefully observes Mark Twain, who she calls Papa, and records her observations in a biography she hides under her pillow. Susy writes about Papa’s habits, marriage, childhood, writing process, and visits to Quarry Farm. Mark Twain was so pleased with the well-rounded picture of him that Susy wrote that he published his favorite parts of her biography in his autobiography.



Critical Analysis


Barbara Kerley has been praised for the “accuracy, dynamism, and flair” of her picture book biographies. Her use of primary sources adds to the credibility of this story. In a feature that will be popular with children, small pages labeled as a journal are found between the oversized pages of this book. Within them are lines from Susy’s actual journal, in a script-like font and complete with her "frequently desperate" spellings. Additionally, there are real quotes from both Susy and Mark Twain woven throughout the story, each with their own font that is larger and more stylized than the rest of the text. Sources are provided for all the quotations, as well as acknowledgement that the manuscript of Susy Clemens’ biography of Mark Twain was made available by the Albert and Shirley Small Collections, University of Virginia Library. An Author’s Note on both Papa and Susy, guide to “Writing An Extraordinary Biography,” timeline, and real photograph of the family are provided at the end of the book as well.


The story is told from thirteen-year-old Susy’s perspective, making it more relatable for younger audiences. The layout of journal entries appearing to be in their own book makes it easy to recognize Susy’s actual words from the supporting words written by Kerley. This format also makes the primary source more desirable to be read by younger audiences.  


Edwin Fotheringham’s digital illustrations in bold colors of a Victorian palette set the scene for this 19th century setting. Large swirling lines resembling the flourishes of an ink pen are found on most pages, subtly and cleverly conveying the emotions and words of the characters on the page. Other details included in the images, such as Twain’s beloved cats, add to the visual appeal and delight of readers.


While young readers may not have heard of Mark Twain’s famous works before reading this book, they are offered a charming first look at this “funny, serious, absentminded, cat-loving, billiard-playing, philosophical Papa.” This engaging and creative biography would be a welcome addition to any library! 



Awards & Reviews


Orbis Pictus Award Commended Book

CCBC Choice Selection

Notable Children’s Books in the Language Arts Award Selection

A Junior Library Guild Selection

School Library Journal Best Books of the Year 2010

Publishers Weekly Best Children's Books 2010 


Booklist (December 1, 2009 (Vol. 106, No. 7))

…Kerley manages to bring Susy and her famous father to life using plenty of household anecdotes … An original.


Kirkus Reviews starred (December 15, 2009)

Kerley's conversational, quotation-rich narration effectively complements Susy's insights, and the result is an affectionate portrait of Twain as writer and family man. … A heartwarming tribute to both the writing life in general and the well-loved humorist--oops, sorry Susy... "Pholosopher!"


Library Media Connection (May/June 2010)

Students will enjoy the sparse but rich text, Susy’s diary inserts, and bold illustrations in digital media; they will definitely learn something new about the American icon that is Twain as well. Teachers will love the detailed Author’s Notes and timeline of Twain’s life. … This will be a fine addition to any library’s biography section. 


Publishers Weekly (December 14, 2009)

… accessible and inventive vision of an American legend. 


School Library Journal (January 1, 2010)

Kerley and Fotheringham again craft a masterfully perceptive and largely visual biography … A delightful primer on researching and writing biographies, and a joy to peruse.



Connections 


  • Write a biography about a family member. Refer to Barbara Kerley’s step by step directions at the end of the book to guide your research.


  • Visit the Mark Twain Boyhood Home & Museum (https://marktwainmuseum.org/) to learn more about Mark Twain. The physical museum is located in Hannibal, MO, but you can take a virtual tour through the interactive map. The “Learn With Us” tab has more Mark Twain resources for kids and teachers.


  • Make a t-chart of Mark Twain’s external and internal character traits as described by Susy.


  • Read another book about Mark Twain. Compare and contrast the character traits Susy describes with the character traits of Mark Twain in the other book. 



  • Barbara Kerley’s picture book biographies are praised for their accuracy, dynamism, and flair. Read another of her books, such as:

A Home for Mr. Emerson. Ill. by Edwin Fotheringham. ISBN 9780545350884

The Dinosaurs of Waterhouse Hawkins. Ill. by Brian Selznick. ISBN 9780439114943

Eleanor Makes Her Mark. Ill. by Edwin Fotheringham.  ISBN 9780545826129

Walt Whitman: Words for America. Ill. by Brian Selznick. ISBN 9780439357913


No comments:

Post a Comment