Friday, June 30, 2023

Mirror Mirror by Marilyn Singer and illustrated by Josée Masse

 A book cover of a mirror

Description automatically generated with low confidence


Singer, Marilyn. 2010. Mirror Mirror. Ill. by Josée Masse. New York, NY: Dutton Children’s Books. ISBN 9780525479017


Summary

“Who says it’s true – down is the only view? If you believe that, this poem will challenge you. Up is something new.”

Mirror Mirror is a book of poems that challenge our perspective on familiar fairy tale characters, showing that there are two sides to every story. The well-known stories these poems are based on include Cinderella, Sleepy Beauty, Rapunzel, Red Riding Hood, the Ugly Duckling, Snow White, Jack and the Beanstalk, Goldilocks and the Three Bears, Hansel and Gretal, Rumpelstiltskin, Princess and the Frog, and Beauty and the Beast. Most poems show two differing viewpoints of the same situation, such as Red Riding Hood and the Wolf or Sleeping Beauty and the Wide-Awake Prince. A humorous twist on the traditional tales!


Critical Analysis

The reversible verse poem is a clever design author Marilyn Singer created and named the reverso. One free verse stanza is read top to bottom as usual, accompanied by another stanza with the same lines listed in reverse, as if the original poem was read bottom to top. With only changes in capitalization and punctuation allowed, a whole new meaning still takes place. Reversos are a creative and well-suited choice for showing alternate views. They would fit exceedingly well with a lesson on character perspectives. It’s rather remarkable how the same words not only make sense when read in reverse, but also tell their own story!

The arrangement of the poem stanzas paired next to each other with different font and background colors is very effective. Each poem is accompanied by a single image centered below the poem that applies to both stories, like a broken chair for Goldilocks and the Three Bears. As if the poems weren’t clever enough, Josée Masse’s vibrant, creative illustrations artfully enhance the duality of the poem in striking ways. Cut down the center, each perspective is shown in its own column, yet with similar lines flowing from one image to the other. In “Bears in the News,” half the image shows Goldilocks screaming as bear shadows approach, while the other half is a mirror image, but with goldilocks in shadows startling the friendly looking bears. Singer and Masse’s witty pairing of language, imagery, design, and perspective make this delightful collection of poems a must have for every library!


Awards & Reviews

ALA Notable Children's Books, 2011
Cybil Award in Poetry winner
Land of Enchantment Picture Book Award winner
Texas Bluebonnet Award nominee
Horn Book Fanfare list
New York Public Library's 2010 Best 100 Children's Books
2010 Chicago Public Library Best of the Best Books
Betsy Bird's 100 Magnificent Children's Books of 2010
Publishers Weekly's Best Children's Books of 2010
Booklist's Editors' Choice list
Washington Post's Top 15 Children's Books of 2010.

Booklist starred (January 1, 2010 (Vol. 106, No. 9))
… irreverently witty poems and brilliantly employ artistic elements of form and shape. … A must-purchase that will have readers marveling over a visual and verbal feast.

Horn Book Magazine (March/April, 2010)
… the poems are both cleverly constructed and insightful about their source stories, giving us the points of view of characters rarely considered.

Kirkus Reviews starred (February 15, 2010)
A mesmerizing and seamless celebration of language, imagery and perspective.

Library Media Connection (May/June 2010)
Truly a visual, as well as a literary, puzzle and such a treat!

Publishers Weekly (February 8, 2010)
Masse's clever compositions play with symmetry … bringing this smart concept to its fullest effect.


Connections
  • Choose a poem from the book and use a Venn diagram to compare and contrast the two views presented in the poem.
  • The Great Fairy-Tale Debate: Have students choose a poem from Mirror Mirror and find a fractured fairy tale that pairs with the story. Two students will take the side of different characters from the story in a classroom debate. The rest of the class can ask questions of the characters then vote on whose side to choose!
  • Create your own reverso poem with an illustration where parts of the picture are changed to other objects in the second half of the image.
  • If you enjoyed Marilyn Singer’s reverso poems accompanied by Josée Masse’s illustrations, be sure to check out their other reverso poems books:
Singer, Marilyn. Follow Follow: A Book of Reverso Poems. Ill. by Josée Masse. ISBN 9780803737693
Singer, Marilyn. Echo Echo: Reverso Poems About Greek Myths. Ill. by Josée Masse. ISBN 9780803739925

 


This Is Just to Say: Poems of Apology and Forgiveness by Joyce Sidman and illustrated by Pamela Zagarenski

 A picture containing text, drawing, illustration, handwriting

Description automatically generated


Sidman, Joyce. 2007. This Is Just to Say: Poems of Apology and Forgiveness. Ill. by Pamela Zagarenski. New York, NY: Houghton Mifflin. ISBN 9780618616800


Summary

“We hope you enjoy reading our poems. As Mrs. Merz says, there is a little bit of us in each of them.”
This charming anthology of short poems was started by a fictional sixth grade class of students who were inspired by the poem, “This Is Just to Say,” by William Carlos Williams. The book is comprised of apology poems written by Mrs. Merz’s students, as well as poem responses back from the recipients. The poems range from humorous and silly to heartwarming and sincere. Topics covered by the poems are wide-ranging and relatable to readers. The apology poems include topics such as: a rough game of dodgeball, snagging treats you aren’t supposed to eat, breaking things that aren’t yours, unrequited crushes, loss of a pet, and family relationships.


Critical Analysis

Pamela Zagarenski’s colorful illustrations give the anthology a light-hearted feel. They are a collage of mixed media and computer graphics with bold background colors. Attention to detail is well thought out, including clippings of the dictionary entry for the word apology.

The strongest feature of Joyce Sidman’s anthology is the way humorous everyday situations are mixed with serious, tougher topics. Something about the poems being composed as letters made them tap deeper into emotions than just a regular book of poems. Letters are, by their very nature, personal because they are a message directed toward one person or audience. Writing letters through poetry allowed the “authors” to share their thoughts and feelings in a raw, unfiltered way, where regular grammar conventions aren’t as important as the message. While the poetry format gives the letters a more playful feel, there are still strongly expressed feelings of loss, disappointment, and embarrassment.

Most of the poems are written in free verse, but for such a large poem collection it would have been nice to see more specific types of poems represented. The “Author’s Note” explaining the pantoum form of Anthony’s poem was a great educational feature. It seems a lost opportunity to not include this on multiple poems to introduce different poem styles to readers. It also would have been nice to see more rhyme and rhythm included in the poems so the apologies would feel more like poems and less like regular letters.

The poems are mostly unrelated, other than between the apologizer and recipient, but the author does a nice job of adding some connections between them. Maria’s mom responds to her daughter’s poem, “Brownies – Oops!” with her own poem, “Desk Mess – Oops!” in which she talks about seeing the letter written to Maria by Bobby. There are also several responses written by classmates when the original recipient wouldn’t or couldn’t respond.

The responses brought up themes of understanding and forgiveness and showed a lot about different relationship dynamics. The addition of this part of the book gave some satisfying closure to the situations addressed by the initial apologies. Some recipients, such as Alyssa’s sister, did not accept the apology they were given. Others, such as the responses from Jose’s dad and Mrs. Merz’s mother, were extremely touching and even more so when you imagined the apologizer receiving the note. It would be nearly impossible to not tear up from the serious situation between Jewel and her estranged father – that in itself is powerful. This Is Just to Say is a satisfying read that will hopefully inspire its readers to explore their own feelings and write some apology poems of their own!


Awards & Reviews

Claudia Lewis Poetry Award
Cybils Poetry Award
Lee Bennett Hopkins Poetry Award Honor Book

Booklist (May 15, 2007 (Vol. 103, No. 18))
… a captivating anthology of short poems in various styles touching on different aspects of life.
Children will find much to identify with in the situations presented in the apology poems, and they'll appreciate the resolutions given in the responses.

Horn Book Guide (Fall 2007)
… intimate, often touching glimpses of relationships by which real classes might be inspired.

Kirkus Reviews (March 15, 2007)
Packed with the intensity of everyday pain and sorrow, kids and adults exchange the words that convey grief, delight, love and acceptance of themselves and others.

Library Media Connection (November/December 2007)
Lessons about accepting responsibility, seeking forgiveness, and righting wrongs are all part of the fabric of this book. Each school library could benefit from adding this wonderful book of poems to its collection.

Publishers Weekly (March 5, 2007)
...the poems successfully navigate the complicated terrain for those who seek forgiveness.

School Library Journal (May 1, 2007)
Sidman's ear is keen, capturing many voices. Her skill as a poet accessible to young people is unmatched. … This is an important book both for its creativity and for its wisdom.


Connections
  • Look back at the Author’s Note about Anthony’s pantoum poem on page 22. Try writing a poem yourself using this unique poetic form.
  • Have students write their own apology poems, including both sensory details from the incident as well as their feelings before and after.
  • Create a class book of poems based around a common theme or unit of study, written and illustrated by the students.

Hidden by Helen Frost

A picture containing text, human face, person, child

Description automatically generated 


Frost, Helen. 2011. Hidden. New York, NY: Frances Foster Books. ISBN 9780374382216


Summary

“But we’re determined, and the two of us are stronger than we know.”
At the age of eight, one event changes both Wren and Darra’s lives forever. This three-part novel in verse initially is narrated by Wren, who was accidentally kidnapped by Darra’s father when he stole a car from a parking lot. Only Darra believes that this little girl from the news is hidden in their garage all along. Darra leaves her food and water until eventually Wren manages to escape. The second part of the book is told from Darra’s perspective, as we learn how Wren’s escape changed Darra’s life. She holds a lot of anger for her father’s arrest – at Wren for leading the police to her house, at her parents who she believes are lying about releasing Wren, and even at her dog Bilbo, who she feels betrayed her family to the police. We are brought back to the present in the part three, when the girls are reunited at Camp Oakwood as fourteen years old. They quickly realize who each other is but pretend not to know. They manage to avoid one another until an activity in Lifesaving class forces them to confront each other. A friendship forms and through it the girls learn parts of their shared past that they never know. Wren and Darra help each other heal and learn how to forgive not only others in their lives, but themselves as well.


Critical Analysis

Helen Frost’s telling of this story is a clever example of how verse novels have the potential to weave together a story in different and interesting ways. The way the poems are arranged on the page offers more to the story than the words alone. Different poem styles are used for each girl, differentiating their voices. Wren’s poems are written in free verse broken into stanzas, giving her passages a more lyrical, organized quality. In Part One there are also numbered sections indicating the passage of time.

Darra’s poems are written in a form invented by Frost for this book, in which the last word of the long lines form hidden sentences giving more insight into the story. In Part Two, the hidden sentences reveal memories of her father from before Wren’s part of the story began. This helps the reader understand Darra’s feelings about him, despite how we have seen him behave so far. In Part Three, the hidden messages reveal how Darra experienced the event from when they were eight, which was previously only told from Wren’s perspective.

The first two parts of the books when the girls were eight is written in past tense poems, while the third part of the book is written in present tense, indicating not only a gap in time but that these memories have stuck with Wren and Darra and shaped how they think. There is also no description of how the girls look until the third part of the book, challenging how some readers may have assumed each girl looked based on the cover art. We learn about our assumptions in much the same way that Wren does.

Hidden is an appropriate and curious name for this book, as many meanings could be applied to it. Just as Wren was hidden in the garage, Darra’s memories are hidden in her poems. Their shared experience is also hidden from those around them as they have tried to remove themselves from the event that clearly still haunted them both.

This story explores themes of friendship and forgiveness in a way that will really resonate with both teens and adults alike. We see how without the full story, assumptions become our reality, and only through facing these straight on can we move on ourselves. This verse novel is a must have for every secondary library!


Awards & Reviews

ALA Notable Children's Book
William Allan White Award—2014 Winner,
Lee Bennett Hopkins Children’s Poetry Award, Honor book
CCBC Choices
Bank Street Best Children’s Books, Starred
2012 IRA (International Reading Association) Teachers’ Choices
VOYA’s “Perfect 10” List
Kirkus Review’s Best Children’s books of 2011
Richie Partington’s “Best of 2011” list
Sylvia Vardell’s “Top 20 Children’s Poetry Books of 2011”
Paul Hankin’s “Top ten plus 1” list of 2011 Middle Grade Fiction

Booklist (April 1, 2011 (Vol. 107, No. 15))
… this novel in verse stands out through its deliberate use of form to illuminate emotions and cleverly hide secrets in the text.

Horn Book Guide (Fall 2011)
The story's ripped-from-the-headlines elements are entirely plausible in Frost's capable hands.

Kirkus Reviews starred (April 1, 2011)
From the award-winning Frost comes a wildly imaginative, thought-provoking novel in verse … Both tender and insightful, this well-crafted, fast-paced tale should have wide teen appeal.

Library Media Connection (August/September 2011)
This amazing story is portrayed beautifully through poetry. … Middle and high school students will relish the development of this unlikely friendship. This title is a must-have for secondary library collections. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED

School Library Journal (June 1, 2011)
This original blend of crime tale, psychological study, and friendship story is a page-turner that kids will love.


Connections
  • Try writing hidden message poems in Darra’s style, where the last words of long lines will form sentences while read down the page.
  • Create your own campfire circle with stones to represent the friendships of your class. Students can write on real rocks or create a flat version out of paper.




Odder by Katherine Applegate and illustrated by Charles Santoso

 A picture containing text, mammal, bear, marine mammal

Description automatically generated


Applegate, Katherine. 2022. Odder. Ill. by Charles Santoso. New York, NY: Feiwel & Friends. ISBN 9781250147424


Summary

“Why simply dive when she could dazzle?”
Odder follows the story of a daring and adventurous sea otter in Monterey Bay, California. Based loosely on the story of real sea otters at the Monterey Bay Aquarium, we are given a touching inside look at the story from an animal’s perspective. The story is broken up into three parts and a coda. In “The Queen of play” we see daring Odder’s love of playing with her more cautious friend Kairi. Despite her mother’s repeated advice, “Stay away from sharks. Stay away from humans. Stay away from all that you don’t understand,” we learn that daredevil Odder is often curiously exploring close to humans and pushing the boundaries of the bay. Poems about a nearby shark add some foreboding foreshadowing that their paths may cross at some point. When the otters swim out too far, they have a terrifying encounter with the shark, leaving brave Odder injured. When she is rescued on the shore by the aquarium staff, we learn that she was there as a pup. Part two, “How to Be an Otter Pup,” tells of Odder’s backstory from three years earlier. After being separated from her mother the aquarium staff taught her how to be an otter, referring to her only as Otter #156 in plans of returning her to the bay. Part three brings us back to the present with the curious title of “Otter #209.” After making the painful determination that Otter #156 cannot again return to the bay without risk, she is reunited with Kairi. The staff bring Odder a helpless pup, Otter #209, hoping she will help teach it how to swim and behave like an otter. After she stubbornly ignores the pup for days, Odder eventually realizes she can teach the pup to play and embraces the role. In a heartwarming ending, Odder proudly says goodbye to the little otter she taught, who is being returned to the water.


Critical Analysis

Katherine Applegate’s use of free verse gives the story a playful feel that serves to emphasize Odder’s nature. The lyrical phrasing of the text aids in giving the impression that the thoughts are coming from the otter’s perspective, rather than from an author talking about the otters. Applegate excels at using imagery to paint a picture of not only the sights of the bay and aquarium, but the smells and sounds as well. Factual information is effortlessly woven into this novel in verse, making it accessible and understandable to young readers.

Where this book really shines is in the emotional impact that comes from viewing the world through an otter’s eyes. This is especially charming to the reader as we see Odder’s view of the humans who care for her. The language of the text makes this viewpoint both believable and humorous. For instance, Odder’s observes that these animals called humans have awkward paws with stubby tentacles (hands) and practically bald bodies. Especially when paired with the adorable black and white drawings of her fuzzy face, you cannot help but fall in love with affectionate, curious, bold Odder!


Awards & Reviews

A #1 New York Times bestseller
A Publishers Weekly bestseller
A #1 Indie Bestseller!
A 2023 Notable Verse Novel, National Council of Teachers of English (NCTE)
An Amazon Best Book of 2022
Parents Magazine Best Book of 2022
A 2022 Blue Ribbon List selection
2022-2023 Vermont Golden Dome Book Award Master List
Evanston Public Library 2022 Blueberry Fiction Honor Title

Booklist starred (August 2022 (Vol. 118, No. 22))
… this gorgeous story is told in flowing free verse that slips by as silkily as an otter in water. … A stunning study of a remarkable and resilient sea creature.

Horn Book Magazine (November/December, 2022)
Applegate grounds the story in scientific fact, slipping in interesting details in a lyrical way … very accessible and appealing to young animal lovers.

Kirkus Reviews (September 15, 2022)
The free verse effortlessly weaves in scientific information, giving Odder a voice without overly anthropomorphizing any of the animals. … Rich, naturalistic details will delight lovers of marine life.

Publishers Weekly starred (August 1, 2022)
Writing in exquisitely descriptive free verse, Applegate delivers an uplifting tale of an inquisitive sea otter pup raised by scientists after being separated from her mother. … the focus remains rightfully on its enigmatic star: a lovable otter who not only survives against the odds but thrives.

School Library Journal (October 1, 2022)
This book will appeal to animal lovers and anyone who feels a little stifled by convention. Hand this book to middle grade fans of marine biology, authors like Sharon Creech and Eliot Schrefer, and Applegate's Newbery-winning The One and Only Ivan.


Connections
  • Plan your reading to coincide with World Otter Day on the last Wednesday of May. This day aims to raise awareness about otters and promote their conservation. Make posters or videos to teach others about the importance of otters for our ecosystem and how to help protect them.
  • Want to help save wildlife and learn more about animals? Each purchase of a bracelet from Fahlo (https://myfahlo.com/) allows you to track a real wild animal through your phone, table, or computer. The company donate a percentage of the sales to non-profit organizations, with the goal of educating customers about wildlife and exciting them about conservation.
  • If you enjoyed this book, you may also like: 
Applegate, Katherine. The One and Only Ivan. Ill. by Patricia Castelao ISBN 9780061992278 (A Newbery Award Winner and now a major motion picture)
O’Connor, Barbara. Wish. ISBN 9781250144058
Parry, Rosanne. A Whale of the Wild. ISBN 9780062995933

Monday, June 19, 2023

The Three Pigs by David Wiesner

 A book cover for three pigs

Description automatically generated with low confidence


Wiesner, David. 2001. The Three Pigs. New York, NY: Clarion Books. ISBN 9780618007011


Summary

This story starts out looking and sounding like the traditional story The Three Pigs we’ve all heard many times. Things change dramatically when the wolf huffed and puffed and… blew the first little pig right out of the story! The perplexed wolf continues on in the story while all the little pigs escape the story, looking more realistic than their former fairy tale selves. They end up entering other stories, changing appearances to match the genre, and meeting new friends who join them on their journey. The cat and the fiddle follows them out of a nursery rhyme, and the pigs help a dragon escape a prince’s sword in a black and white fairy tale. Eventually they decide to return to their own story with their new friends and put the pages back together. However, after all that they couldn’t just return to the regular old story as it was written… As they open the brick house’s front door to the baffled wolf, the dragon knocks the story words off the page. They collect the words to arrange, “And they lived happily ever after.” on their new final page as they enjoy a meal together.


Critical Analysis

This story will charm and delight all fans of traditional tales. The true genius in this book is the way the artwork changes as the pigs enter and exit different worlds. They go from a two-dimensional life on the page of a book to a three-dimensional world outside of it. Readers won’t be able to stop themselves from laughing when they see the puzzled wolf looking around for the pig while the text above him describes him eating the pig up. At one point while the pigs are between pages, one of the pigs is draws very large and squinting, appearing to be moving close to the reader. As he peers out saying, “I think… someone’s out there,” the reader feels another wall is broken and he is looking out at you beyond the book.

The styles of the different artwork match the traditional styles of each piece of literature. In the original tale, the line drawings, muted color, and traditional black font reflect the style most often seen in the traditional tale. The nursery rhyme has bright, colorful, simple images with large, curved letters. The fairly tale has traditional test at the top and black line drawings on white paper. After leaving the book pages and entering a three-dimensional world, the text switches to speech bubbles from the pigs, without a narrator on the page. The images are much more detailed with lines and motion.

The use of shading to create shadows is executed brilliantly. The other strategy David Wiesner used that adds so much to the pictures is having animals in two different styles as they are exiting the book pages. For example, as the pigs appear to be jumping out of the nursery rhyme, their back halves are in nursery rhyme styles as their front halves, already out of the page, are back to the 3-D style. What makes this even more brilliant is that the pigs have both the green shadow in the nursery rhyme as well as the grey shadow from the 3-D bodies coming out of the page.

It takes remarkable talent to illustrate in many different styles, but even more-so to encompass two different perspectives in one picture. The Caldecott Medal was well deserved for Wiesner’s work in this story! A must-have for any library shelf.


Awards & Reviews


Caldecott Medal, 2002

Irma Black Award, 2002

ALA Notable Children's Books, 2002


Booklist starred (May 15, 2001 (Vol. 97, No. 18))

Wiesner has created a funny, wildly imagined tale that encourages kids to leap beyond the familiar, to think critically about conventional stories and illustration, and perhaps to flex their imaginations and create wonderfully subversive versions of their own stories.


Horn Book Guide starred (Fall, 2001)

… a fantastic journey told with a light touch.


Publishers Weekly (February 26, 2001)

Wiesner … evokes a feeling that the characters can navigate endless possibilities–and that the range of story itself is limitless. 


School Library Journal (April 2001)

Witty dialogue and physical comedy abound in this inspired retelling of a familiar favorite.



Connections 



  • Other traditional literature Caldecott Honor Books you may enjoy:

Isaacs, Anne. Swamp Angel. Ill. by Paul O. Zelinsky. ISBN 9780525452713

Scieszka, Jon. The Stinky Cheese Man and Other Fairly Stupid Tales. Ill. by Lane Smith. ISBN 9780670844876

Taback, Simms. Joseph Had a Little Overcoat. ISBN 9780670878550

Taback, Simms. There Was an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Fly. ISBN 9780670869398

Zelinsky, Paul O. Rapunzel. ISBN 9780525456070


  • Reading Enrichment Activity: Compare and contrast this story to other variants or versions of The Three Pigs. 


  • Writing Enrichment Activity: Have students choose a familiar fairy tale or folktale. Allow them to draw and write their version of what might happen if their characters could leave the story. 


  • Perspective Enrichment Activity: Examine how the change of perspective in this version of the classic tale changes your opinions of the characters from the traditional tale. More The Three Pigs books with a shift in perspective include:

Gunderson, Jessica. No Lie, Pigs (and Their Houses) Can Fly!: The Story of the Three Little Pigs as Told by the Wolf (The Other Side of the Story). Ill. by Cristian Luis Bernardini. ISBN 9781479586257

Teague, Mark. The Three Little Pigs and the Somewhat Bad Wolf. ISBN 9780545652728

Trivizas, Eugene. The Three Little Wolves and the Big Bad Pig. ISBN 9780689505690



Anansi and the Talking Melon retold by Eric A. Kimmel and illustrated by Janet Stevens

 A book cover holding a basketball

Description automatically generated with medium confidence


Kimmel, Eric A. 1994. Anansi and the Talking Melon. Ill. by Janet Stevens. New York, NY:  Holiday House. ISBN 9780823411047



Summary


This funny African folktale begins with Anansi the Spider, who is too lazy to grow his own melons, sneaking into Elephant’s garden to eat his biggest, ripest melon. After eating he becomes too fat to squeeze out of the tiny hole he climbed in. Bored Anansi decides to entertain himself by tricking Elephant into thinking the melon was talking. Elephant sets off to show the king, picking up some gullible friends along the way, who believe Anansi’s insults came from the melon. Elephant makes his way to the king with Hippo, Warthog, Ostrich, Rhino, and Turtle to convince the king the melon talks. Unlike before, the melon stays quiet, angering the impatient monkey king. However, that’s nothing compared to his anger when the sassy melon calls him stupid for talking to a melon! In the end Elephant learns that “Talking melons are nothing but trouble.”



Critical Analysis


Anansi the Trickster may come from West African folklore, but Eric A. Kimmel and Janet Stevens make a great team retelling the story with their own unique touch. Kimmel sets the scene with his descriptive language of the warm, sunny day in the garden where Anansi eats the juicy and sweet melons until he was “as round as a berry.” The repeated pattern in the way the story is told is appealing to children, and the laughs are well placed throughout the story. Readers can’t help but giggle when they realize Anansi is up to his old tricks again at the end of the story, talking as the bananas. 


Stevens’ illustrations greatly add to the humor. Some laughs are obvious, like seeing Hippo sitting with his legs crossed in a lounge chair, reading a book under an umbrella. Others will delight readers when they spot them, such as seeing Anansi poking out of the melon in every image, even when the characters themselves do not see him. The closeup line-and-wash illustrations of the animals’ faces are especially wonderful examples of using texture and line to capture emotions. Stevens’ anthropomorphic style allows the reader to see the animals’ worry, suspicion, anger, and wonder as they gaze at the talking melon. The use of color captivates the reader as well. The two-page spread of the melon from Anansi’s perspective as he bore a hole draws you in. Contrast between the grays and browns of the animals and the bright greens, yellows, and pinks of the surrounding plants are visually appealing and well executed. 


This book will have you laughing at Anansi’s tricks and being charmed by the delightfully illustrated animals. A great choice for storytelling and read-alouds!



Awards & Reviews


National Council of Teachers of English Award Books, 1994

Beehive Children's Picture Book Award 1998

Show Me Readers Award 1996 - 1997


Booklist (Vol. 90, No. 12 (February 15, 1994))

With perfect pacing and repetition and with surprising reversals up to the very last page, this is a great choice for reading aloud and storytelling.


Kirkus Reviews starred (1994)

Good-spirited tomfoolery, with storytelling that reels along with the ease of a seasoned prankster.


School Library Journal (March 1994)

A surefire hit.



Connections 



  • More books about Anansi the Trickster retold by Eric Kimmel and illustrated by Janet Stevens:

Anansi and the Moss-Covered Rock. ISBN 9780823407989

Anansi Goes Fishing. ISBN 9780823410224

Anansi and the Magic Stick. ISBN 9780823417636

Anansi’s Party Time. ISBN 9780823422418


  • Other children’s books with African folktales:

Aardema, Verna. Why Mosquitoes Buzz in People’s Ears. Ill. By Leo and Diane Dillon. ISBN 9780140549058

Gerson, Mary-Joan. Why the Sky is Far Away: A Nigerian Folktale. ISBN 9780316308748

Haley, Gail E. A Story, a Story. ISBN 9780689712012

McDermott, Gerald. Anansi the Spider: A Tale from the Ashanti. ISBN 9780805003116


  • Mapping Anansi Enrichment Activity: Have students look in atlases and books about Africa to find out where the animals in the story make their homes. On an outline map of Africa, have students use drawings to show where on the continent the various animals in the story can be found. Animal research can also be done to learn about the kinds of homes made by each animal.


Swamp Angel by Anne Isaacs and illustrated by Paul O. Zelinsky

 A book cover of a book

Description automatically generated with low confidence

Isaacs, Anne. 1994. Swamp Angel. Ill. by Paul O. Zelinsky. New York, NY: Dutton Children’s Books. ISBN 9780525452713


Summary

“To this day, stories about Swamp Angel spring up like sunflowers along the wagon trails. And every one of them is true.” Born in 1815 as Angelica Longrider in the woods of Tennessee, Swamp Angel was scarcely taller than her mother and building log cabins by the age of two. This larger-than-life character got her nickname by lifting covered wagons stuck in Dejection Swamp “like they were twigs in a puddle.” She goes on to sign up for the hunt of a humongous bear known as Thundering Tarnation. From tossing him so high into sky he crashed into the stars to lassoing him with a tornado, Swamp Angel engages in an epic battle with the creature, creating well known landmarks along the way.


Critical Analysis

When I saw the unique and striking illustration style of American primitive style oil paintings on cherry and maple veneers, I expected the pictures would carry this story. However, Anne Isaacs holds her own with creative language that fits seamlessly with the setting. It feels like you’re being told the story from someone who was actually in the Tennessee wilderness watching these adventures happen.

The story is full of creative and zany figurative language that it seems could only have existed in this backwoods Tennessee setting. This book would make a great study on writing imaginative similes. A blend of understatement and exaggeration bring humor and surprise to this tall tale. This original story also contains the common elements of tall tales, such as amazing childhood abilities (building a log cabin at two years old), real-life landform creation by the actions of the characters (the Great Smoky Mountains, the Shortgrass Prairie, and the great bear constellation), and a larger-than-life heroine beating out forces of nature. It’s quite a feat to match the storytelling style itself to the time of the story in the way Isaacs does. Paul O. Zelinsky’s primitive American style artwork pairs perfectly with this setting. Muted color tones in oval frames give the pictures an old-timey feel. It is easy to see that the Caldecott Honor was well deserved. This book is a classic tall tale in the making that will capture the hearts of readers of all ages.


Awards & Reviews

1995 Caldecott Honor Book
2013 Phoenix Picture Book Award by the Children's Literature Association
1995 Boston Globe-Horn Book Honor Book
1994 ALA Notable Book
New York Public Library, 100 Books Every Child Should Read
New York Times Best Illustrated Books of 1994
School Library Journal Best Books of 1994
Booklist Children's Editors Choices 1994
Publisher's Weekly Best Books of 1994
Time Magazine's 8 Best Children's Books, 1994
Parenting Magazine Reading-Magic Award, 10 Best Books of 1994
1995 Notable Trade Book in Language Arts, National Council of Teachers of English

Booklist starred (Vol. 91, No. 4 (October 15, 1994))
Isaacs tells her original story with the glorious exaggeration and uproarious farce of the traditional tall tale and with its typical laconic idiom--you just can't help reading it aloud.

Kirkus Reviews starred (1994)
It is impossible to convey the sheer pleasure, the exaggerated loopiness, of newcomer Isaacs's wonderful story. … To say that you are entering Caldecott land doesn't begin to do this book justice.

Publishers Weekly (October 3, 1994)
This valiant heroine is certain to leave youngsters chuckling-and perhaps even keeping a close watch on the night sky.

School Library Journal (December 1994)
Thundering Tarnation! With its good-natured, larger-than-life heroine and broad, fanciful paintings, this original Tennessee tall tale is exhilarating and side-splittingly funny.

School Library Journal (December 1994)
Buy for a great guffaw in small groups or one-on-one. It's an American classic in the making.


Connections

  • If you enjoyed this story, you can see more of Swamp Angel in Anne Isaac’s “thrilling, thigh-slapping companion to Swamp Angel,” Devil Dust. ISBN 9781416902003
  • More books with larger-than-life tall tale characters:
    Kellogg, Steven. Paul Bunyan, A Tall Tale. ISBN 9780688058005
    Mora, Pat. Doña Flor: A Tall Tale about a Giant Woman with a Great Big Heart. ISBN 978-0375861444
    Lester, Julius. John Henry. Ill. by Jerry Pinkney. ISBN 9780140566222
  • Tall Tale Writing Enrichment Activity: Have student work individually or in pairs to create their own tall tale, making sure to include elements from the following checklist: amazing abilities seen at birth and early childhood; real-life landforms such as canyons or lakes explained by fictional actions of hero/heroine; and a basic theme of underdog beating out forces of nature that are normally impossible to stop (thunderstorms, hurricanes, tidal waves, earthquakes, etc.)
  • Figurative Language Enrichment Activity: We read that, “stories about Swamp Angel spring up like sunflowers along the wagon trails.” This story is full of amazingly creative similes. Find and make a list of all the similes in this story. Then try to come up with some descriptive and imaginative similes of your own.

The Three Little Fish and the Big Bad Shark by Ken Geist and illustrated by Julia Gorton

 A picture containing text, poster, cartoon, fish

Description automatically generated

Geist, Ken. 2007. The Three Little Fish and the Big Bad Shark. Ill. by Julia Gorton. New York, NY: Scholastic Inc. ISBN 9780545102476


Summary

Mama fish sends her three little fish out into the deep blue sea to build their own homes. Jim’s weedy little seaweed house and Tim’s sandy little sandcastle house cannot withstand the Big Bad Shark’s munching and crunching. They escape and seek refuge in their smart sister Kim’s house in an old wooden ship. Attempting to smash this house as well leaves the shark toothless and eating seaweed from a shell bowl while the fishy trio celebrates.


Critical Analysis

This underwater adaptation of The Three Little Pigs and The Big Bad Wolf follows the familiar storyline with an aquatic twist. Readers will enjoy the altered versions of the recognizable elements from the traditional tale such as the line, “Not by the skin of my finny fin fin!” There’s no huffing and puffing in this story, but the toothy predator threatens to munch, crunch, and smash their house in. The story is predictable for anyone who knows the original tale, but children will enjoy the surprise ending.

Julia Gorton’s digitally rendered illustrations really bring Ken Geist’s words to life, with bold-colored, full-page images. The words become part of the story – falling out of the shark’s mouth while he gets a mouthful of sandcastle crumbles and swirling in the current of the escaping little fish. The three little fish have expressive, friendly faces. The small, distinguishable differences (Jim’s top fin curl, Tim’s freckles, and Kim’s eyelashes and rosy cheeks) give them personality and allow the reader to see the little fish as separate characters. Some of the pictures are rather busy with details, which could either distract or delight readers. This is a fun read that all fans of fractured fairy tales will enjoy!


Awards & Reviews

IRA Children's Choice

School Library Journal (June 1, 2007)
The tale of "The Three Little Pigs" gets an underwater makeover in this snappy yarn. … This spunky tale is a welcome addition to storytime and picture-book collections.

Kirkus Reviews (April 1, 2007)
This aquatic update on the classic pig story is sure to enthrall readers young and old … Great for educators teaching comparisons, and for ocean lovers.

Library Media Connection (October 2007)
This story is a variant of the "Three Little Pigs," and it works wonderfully.


Connections

  • If you enjoyed this fractured fairy tale, you may enjoy these other versions of The Three Pigs, where the characters are also reimagined as other creatures:
    McNamara, Margaret & Mark Fearing. The Three Little Aliens and the Big Bad Robot. ISBN 9780375866890
    Kimmel, Eric A. The Three Little Tamales. Ill. by Valeria Docampo. ISBN 9780761455196
    Lowell, Susan. The Three Little Javelinas. Ill. by Jim Harris. ISBN 9780873585422
  • Story Elements Enrichment: Create a Venn diagram to compare and contrast this version of the tale to the traditional tale. Which elements of the story remained the same? Which elements changed for this underwater setting?
  • Storytelling Enrichment: Have students practice storytelling by retelling this story, encouraging the use of expression and props.
  • Writing Enrichment: Rewrite your own version of this classic tale. What kind of animals will your characters be? What kinds of houses will they build? How will you change the well-known, repeated question and answer responses to match your new characters and setting?

Saturday, June 10, 2023

Leonardo the Terrible Monster by Mo Willems

 

A picture containing text, cartoon, font, poster

Description automatically generated

Willems, Mo. 2005. Leonardo the Terrible Monster. New York, NY: Scholastic. ISBN 9781338343632



Summary

This simple and humorous children’s book features Leonardo, a monster who is terrible at being scary. He just isn’t big enough, weird enough, or teethy enough to scare anyone. He comes up with a plan to find the most “scaredy-cat kid in the whole world” and “scare the tuna salad out of him!” While it initially appears his plan has worked, it turns out the little boy was just having a bad day. Leonardo decides that instead of being a terrible monster he would instead become a wonderful friend.



Critical Analysis


Mo Willems delivers another quick and humorous book with lovable, quirky characters. The title offers a play on words, as one would normally expect a terrible monster to be a horrible one, but we quickly find out that he is just terrible at being a monster. The story offers a simple, easy to understand lesson about friendship for young children.


As with his other books, Willems’ illustrations feature simple line designs and characters with exaggerated facial expressions and body language. These appeal to young children especially, as they can spot and recognize the emotions. This book has a color theme of muted pinks, blues, and tans, and seems to have no specified setting or background art. 


The brilliance of Willems book comes from the way things are placed an arranged on a page. Words are written in big, fun font with words or phrases emphasized by being a different color. Part of the humor of this book comes from the juxtaposition of large, mostly blank pages with small, unintimidating characters. The biggest surprise comes when the little boy, Sam, explains why he's crying, filling two whole pages with a run-on sentence explaining everything that has gone wrong, followed by a tiny speech bubble on the following page. Kids will delight in relating to the emotions and actions of the characters. Leonardo the Terrible Monster is a short read, but one that children will want to reread again and again.



Awards & Reviews

ALA Notable Children's Books
2006 Book Sense Book of the Year Honor Book

Booklist (July 2005 (Vol. 101, No. 21))
“Your Pal, Mo Willems," as the cover reads, offers a simple message-driven story, elevated by a smart, striking design. … A winner for story hours, with plenty of discussion possibilities.

Horn Book Magazine (September/October, 2005)
Willems's story plays out like a theatrical performance on tall, uncluttered, muted-color pages. The ornamental, circus-poster-like typeface, in all caps, reinforces this idea, and Willems's sense of pacing helps convey mood. … In lesser hands, this would be a sentimental and saccharine outcome, but Willems pulls it off with panache. This production is just the ticket for preschool story hour.

Kirkus Reviews (July 15, 2005)
The highly predictable ending is made fresh by the superb control of pacing, just-zany-enough sense of humor and body language readers have come to expect from the creator of Pigeon and Knufflebunny.

Library Media Connection (November/December 2005)
The oversized "monster" book format will make for a good read-aloud. There is plenty of goofy kid-friendly humor ("scare the tuna salad out of him") with a sprinkling of more subtle chuckles for the adult reader…

School Library Journal (August 1, 2005)
His antics to produce a scare will have youngsters laughing, while the asterisk next to the number of monster Tony's teeth ("*note: not all teeth shown") will have grown-ups chuckling, too. A surefire hit.


Connections 

  • If you enjoyed the story of Leonardo and Sam, be sure to check out the sequel, Sam the Most Scaredy-Cat Kid in the Whole World. ISBN 9781368002141


  • Visit Mo Willems website (https://pigeonpresents.com/) to see the latest news. Click the “Pals!” tab to learn more about both Leonardo and Sam. 


  • If you liked this book you may enjoy these other Mo Willems series books: 

Don’t Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus. ISBN 9780786819881

Knuffle Bunny: A Cautionary Tale. ISBN 9780786818709

Elephant & Piggie: Today I Will Fly! ISBN 9781423102953


  • Accepting Differences Enrichment Activity: Allow students to all draw their own unique monster. Let students talk about the colors and details of their monster and discuss how each monster is different, but they all have feelings and could become great friends. As an extension students could write their own story about their monster.