Summary
“We hope you enjoy reading our poems. As Mrs. Merz says, there is a little bit of us in each of them.”
This charming anthology of short poems was started by a fictional sixth grade class of students who were inspired by the poem, “This Is Just to Say,” by William Carlos Williams. The book is comprised of apology poems written by Mrs. Merz’s students, as well as poem responses back from the recipients. The poems range from humorous and silly to heartwarming and sincere. Topics covered by the poems are wide-ranging and relatable to readers. The apology poems include topics such as: a rough game of dodgeball, snagging treats you aren’t supposed to eat, breaking things that aren’t yours, unrequited crushes, loss of a pet, and family relationships.
Critical Analysis
Pamela Zagarenski’s colorful illustrations give the anthology a light-hearted feel. They are a collage of mixed media and computer graphics with bold background colors. Attention to detail is well thought out, including clippings of the dictionary entry for the word apology.
The strongest feature of Joyce Sidman’s anthology is the way humorous everyday situations are mixed with serious, tougher topics. Something about the poems being composed as letters made them tap deeper into emotions than just a regular book of poems. Letters are, by their very nature, personal because they are a message directed toward one person or audience. Writing letters through poetry allowed the “authors” to share their thoughts and feelings in a raw, unfiltered way, where regular grammar conventions aren’t as important as the message. While the poetry format gives the letters a more playful feel, there are still strongly expressed feelings of loss, disappointment, and embarrassment.
Most of the poems are written in free verse, but for such a large poem collection it would have been nice to see more specific types of poems represented. The “Author’s Note” explaining the pantoum form of Anthony’s poem was a great educational feature. It seems a lost opportunity to not include this on multiple poems to introduce different poem styles to readers. It also would have been nice to see more rhyme and rhythm included in the poems so the apologies would feel more like poems and less like regular letters.
The poems are mostly unrelated, other than between the apologizer and recipient, but the author does a nice job of adding some connections between them. Maria’s mom responds to her daughter’s poem, “Brownies – Oops!” with her own poem, “Desk Mess – Oops!” in which she talks about seeing the letter written to Maria by Bobby. There are also several responses written by classmates when the original recipient wouldn’t or couldn’t respond.
The responses brought up themes of understanding and forgiveness and showed a lot about different relationship dynamics. The addition of this part of the book gave some satisfying closure to the situations addressed by the initial apologies. Some recipients, such as Alyssa’s sister, did not accept the apology they were given. Others, such as the responses from Jose’s dad and Mrs. Merz’s mother, were extremely touching and even more so when you imagined the apologizer receiving the note. It would be nearly impossible to not tear up from the serious situation between Jewel and her estranged father – that in itself is powerful. This Is Just to Say is a satisfying read that will hopefully inspire its readers to explore their own feelings and write some apology poems of their own!
Awards & Reviews
Claudia Lewis Poetry Award
Cybils Poetry Award
Lee Bennett Hopkins Poetry Award Honor Book
Booklist (May 15, 2007 (Vol. 103, No. 18))
… a captivating anthology of short poems in various styles touching on different aspects of life.
Children will find much to identify with in the situations presented in the apology poems, and they'll appreciate the resolutions given in the responses.
Horn Book Guide (Fall 2007)
… intimate, often touching glimpses of relationships by which real classes might be inspired.
Kirkus Reviews (March 15, 2007)
Packed with the intensity of everyday pain and sorrow, kids and adults exchange the words that convey grief, delight, love and acceptance of themselves and others.
Library Media Connection (November/December 2007)
Lessons about accepting responsibility, seeking forgiveness, and righting wrongs are all part of the fabric of this book. Each school library could benefit from adding this wonderful book of poems to its collection.
Publishers Weekly (March 5, 2007)
...the poems successfully navigate the complicated terrain for those who seek forgiveness.
School Library Journal (May 1, 2007)
Sidman's ear is keen, capturing many voices. Her skill as a poet accessible to young people is unmatched. … This is an important book both for its creativity and for its wisdom.
Connections
- Look back at the Author’s Note about Anthony’s pantoum poem on page 22. Try writing a poem yourself using this unique poetic form.
- Have students write their own apology poems, including both sensory details from the incident as well as their feelings before and after.
- Create a class book of poems based around a common theme or unit of study, written and illustrated by the students.
- Watch author Joyce Sidman read aloud a poem from the book here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lzuPs014N1w
- Use the Reader’s Theater script adapted from this book to perform the stage play: https://www.brookpub.com/default.aspx?pg=sd&p=2437
No comments:
Post a Comment