Summary
This heartwarming tale tells the history of the bear who inspired the classic Winnie-the-Pooh character. The story is told from the unique perspective of a mother telling her son Cole a bedtime story, offering a story within a story. She shares the story of veterinarian army Captain Harry Colebourn and the bear cub he bought off a trapper on his way to treat horses during World War I. The remarkable bear, named Winnipeg as a reminder of Harry’s hometown, charms the officers with her navigating skills and companionship. Several times Harry’s head and heart are at odds, with his heart winning out every time. This leads him to decide to bring Winnie to The London Zoo before his unit ships out to France. This ends the first part of the story, but as Cole’s mother tells him, “Sometimes you have to let one story end so the next one can begin.” That’s when we learn about Winnie’s friendship with a boy named Christopher Robin Milne at The London Zoo. Christopher Robin’s father, A.A. Milne, writes the stories about them that we now know as Winnie-the-Pooh. The story comes full circle as we learn that Harry is Cole’s great-great-grandfather and that sometimes the best stories are true.
Critical Analysis
A first glance through this book makes it immediately clear why this book received a Caldecott Medal, as the stunning illustrations truly bring this story to life. The cover art on both the book jacket and inner cover are striking and appealing. Sophie Blackall’s full-page color illustrations, made with Chinese ink and watercolor on hot-press paper, are extremely detailed and full of texture. Blackall’s attention to detail draws the reader in as well. It’s nearly impossible to turn the page without taking a moment to take it all in.
Emotions are conveyed through the images that are not expressed in the text. When Harry is leaving on the train to training, worry, passion, and sadness are all apparent through the images, helping children who may not have experience with this scenario to understand what it means.
The passage of time and setting is also conveyed through Blackall’s artwork. From bright blues and greens in Canada to muted colors of a rainy England, the mood is set from these full-page images. The colors get warmer as Christopher Robin’s story begins, indicating another shift in tone for the book.
It really hits home that this book is based on a true story when viewing the album that the boy and his mother are viewing together at the end of the book. It contains real historical images from the Colebourn family archive, as well as the photo of Christopher Robin with Winnie and animal record card from the Zoological Society of London.
Lindsay Mattick skillfully weaves the mother and son bedtime story into Winnie’s story at key moment to help the reader understand and relate to parts of the story from a child’s perspective. Their interactions are always in italics and accompanied by a small black and white image of them in bed, which are juxtaposed with the full-page color images of the story the mother is telling. These little interruptions feel natural and add a unique style to the story.
A couple parallels in the story wording have a major impact on the storyline. One is the debate between head and heart in which heart always wins in the end, even when it is not the easiest choice. The other is Harry’s sentiment that, “There is something special about that Bear.” That thought is echoed by Christopher Robin, and then similarly in the end in the heartwarming moment when the mother thinks, “There is something special about this Boy.” Mattick’s literary style and techniques tie the stories together in a package that will appeal to children and adults alike.
Awards & Reviews
2016 Caldecott Medal winner
A New York Times Notable Children's Book of the Year
Winner of the 2015 Caldecott Medal
Horn Book Fanfare
NYPL 100 Titles for Reading and Sharing
Publishers Weekly Best Book of the Year
Booklinks Lasting Connections
Bookpage Best Book of the Year
School Library Journal (August 1, 2015)
A perfect melding of beautiful art with soulful, imaginative writing, this lovely story, penned by Colebourn's great-great granddaughter, is ideal for sharing aloud or poring over individually. VERDICT Children everywhere will enjoy this tale for years. A must-have.
Booklist starred (September 1, 2015 (Vol. 112, No. 1))
Blackall’s warm, beautiful gouache-and-ink illustrations capture an impressive depth of feeling, even in relatively simplified faces. … Little ones who love A. A. Milne’s classic stories will be enchanted by this heartening account of the bear’s real-life origins.
Horn Book Magazine (September/October, 2015)
... as captivating as it is informative, transforming a personal family story into something universally resonant.
Publishers Weekly (July 20, 2015)
Framed as a bedtime story that Mattick tells her toddler son, Cole … the book strikes a lovely, understated tone of wonder and family pride. It also suits Blackall (A Fine Dessert) to a T.
To learn more about illustrator Sophie Blackall’s process in illustrating this story, read her interview with Shelf Awareness: https://www.shelf-awareness.com/issue.html?issue=2673#m31122
Blackall was also a 2019 Caldecott Medal winner for Hello Lighthouse, which she also wrote. She has also illustrated the New York Times best-selling Ivy and Bean series. To learn more about her projects visit her website: https://www.sophieblackall.com/.
For older readers or those who want to hear more of Winnie’s story, there is a novel version of this story, Winnie’s Great War, written by Lindsay Mattick and Josh Greenhut and illustrated by Sophie Blackall. ISBN 9780275947477
Other books about the true story of Winnie:
Shushkewich, Val. The Real Winnie: A One-Of-A-Kind Bear. ISBN 9781896219899
Walker, Sally M. Winnie: The True Story of the Bear Who Inspired Winnie-the-Pooh. Ill. by Jonathan D. Voss. ISBN 9780805097153
Other books about animals in World War I:
Bausum, Ann. Stubby the War Dog: The True Story of World War I's Bravest Dog. ISBN 9781426332661
Greenwood, Mark. The Donkey of Gallipoli: A True Story of Courage in World War I. Ill. by Frane Lessac. ISBN 9780763639136
Greenwood, Mark. Midnight: A True Story of Loyalty in World War I. Ill. by Frane Lessac. ISBN 9780763674663
Family Tree Enrichment: The last pages of Finding Winnie contain a family tree to understand the relationship between Cole and his great-great-grandfather. Show students other examples of family trees and then have them create one for their own family. Challenge students to be creative by reflecting their cultural heritage in the artistic design.
Mapping Winnie’s Journey Enrichment Activity: Have students revisit the pages where Winnie travels by train, ship, and car. Create a map or timeline to show all the places she traveled to in the book. Can you figure out the total distance Winnie traveled?
No comments:
Post a Comment