Wiesner, David. 2001. The Three Pigs. New York, NY: Clarion Books. ISBN 9780618007011
Critical Analysis
This story will charm and delight all fans of traditional tales. The true genius in this book is the way the artwork changes as the pigs enter and exit different worlds. They go from a two-dimensional life on the page of a book to a three-dimensional world outside of it. Readers won’t be able to stop themselves from laughing when they see the puzzled wolf looking around for the pig while the text above him describes him eating the pig up. At one point while the pigs are between pages, one of the pigs is draws very large and squinting, appearing to be moving close to the reader. As he peers out saying, “I think… someone’s out there,” the reader feels another wall is broken and he is looking out at you beyond the book.
The styles of the different artwork match the traditional styles of each piece of literature. In the original tale, the line drawings, muted color, and traditional black font reflect the style most often seen in the traditional tale. The nursery rhyme has bright, colorful, simple images with large, curved letters. The fairly tale has traditional test at the top and black line drawings on white paper. After leaving the book pages and entering a three-dimensional world, the text switches to speech bubbles from the pigs, without a narrator on the page. The images are much more detailed with lines and motion.
The use of shading to create shadows is executed brilliantly. The other strategy David Wiesner used that adds so much to the pictures is having animals in two different styles as they are exiting the book pages. For example, as the pigs appear to be jumping out of the nursery rhyme, their back halves are in nursery rhyme styles as their front halves, already out of the page, are back to the 3-D style. What makes this even more brilliant is that the pigs have both the green shadow in the nursery rhyme as well as the grey shadow from the 3-D bodies coming out of the page.
It takes remarkable talent to illustrate in many different styles, but even more-so to encompass two different perspectives in one picture. The Caldecott Medal was well deserved for Wiesner’s work in this story! A must-have for any library shelf.
Awards & Reviews
Caldecott Medal, 2002
Irma Black Award, 2002
ALA Notable Children's Books, 2002
Booklist starred (May 15, 2001 (Vol. 97, No. 18))
Wiesner has created a funny, wildly imagined tale that encourages kids to leap beyond the familiar, to think critically about conventional stories and illustration, and perhaps to flex their imaginations and create wonderfully subversive versions of their own stories.
Horn Book Guide starred (Fall, 2001)
… a fantastic journey told with a light touch.
Publishers Weekly (February 26, 2001)
Wiesner … evokes a feeling that the characters can navigate endless possibilities–and that the range of story itself is limitless.
School Library Journal (April 2001)
Witty dialogue and physical comedy abound in this inspired retelling of a familiar favorite.
Connections
Watch David Wiesner’s Meet-the-Author mini-documentary about his picture book-making process: https://www.bookconnections.org/author_collection.cgi?id=47&mid=81
Other traditional literature Caldecott Honor Books you may enjoy:
Isaacs, Anne. Swamp Angel. Ill. by Paul O. Zelinsky. ISBN 9780525452713
Scieszka, Jon. The Stinky Cheese Man and Other Fairly Stupid Tales. Ill. by Lane Smith. ISBN 9780670844876
Taback, Simms. Joseph Had a Little Overcoat. ISBN 9780670878550
Taback, Simms. There Was an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Fly. ISBN 9780670869398
Zelinsky, Paul O. Rapunzel. ISBN 9780525456070
Reading Enrichment Activity: Compare and contrast this story to other variants or versions of The Three Pigs.
Writing Enrichment Activity: Have students choose a familiar fairy tale or folktale. Allow them to draw and write their version of what might happen if their characters could leave the story.
Perspective Enrichment Activity: Examine how the change of perspective in this version of the classic tale changes your opinions of the characters from the traditional tale. More The Three Pigs books with a shift in perspective include:
Gunderson, Jessica. No Lie, Pigs (and Their Houses) Can Fly!: The Story of the Three Little Pigs as Told by the Wolf (The Other Side of the Story). Ill. by Cristian Luis Bernardini. ISBN 9781479586257
Teague, Mark. The Three Little Pigs and the Somewhat Bad Wolf. ISBN 9780545652728
Trivizas, Eugene. The Three Little Wolves and the Big Bad Pig. ISBN 9780689505690
No comments:
Post a Comment