Summary
Mama fish sends her three little fish out into the deep blue sea to build their own homes. Jim’s weedy little seaweed house and Tim’s sandy little sandcastle house cannot withstand the Big Bad Shark’s munching and crunching. They escape and seek refuge in their smart sister Kim’s house in an old wooden ship. Attempting to smash this house as well leaves the shark toothless and eating seaweed from a shell bowl while the fishy trio celebrates.
Critical Analysis
This underwater adaptation of The Three Little Pigs and The Big Bad Wolf follows the familiar storyline with an aquatic twist. Readers will enjoy the altered versions of the recognizable elements from the traditional tale such as the line, “Not by the skin of my finny fin fin!” There’s no huffing and puffing in this story, but the toothy predator threatens to munch, crunch, and smash their house in. The story is predictable for anyone who knows the original tale, but children will enjoy the surprise ending.
Julia Gorton’s digitally rendered illustrations really bring Ken Geist’s words to life, with bold-colored, full-page images. The words become part of the story – falling out of the shark’s mouth while he gets a mouthful of sandcastle crumbles and swirling in the current of the escaping little fish. The three little fish have expressive, friendly faces. The small, distinguishable differences (Jim’s top fin curl, Tim’s freckles, and Kim’s eyelashes and rosy cheeks) give them personality and allow the reader to see the little fish as separate characters. Some of the pictures are rather busy with details, which could either distract or delight readers. This is a fun read that all fans of fractured fairy tales will enjoy!
Awards & Reviews
IRA Children's Choice
School Library Journal (June 1, 2007)
The tale of "The Three Little Pigs" gets an underwater makeover in this snappy yarn. … This spunky tale is a welcome addition to storytime and picture-book collections.
Kirkus Reviews (April 1, 2007)
This aquatic update on the classic pig story is sure to enthrall readers young and old … Great for educators teaching comparisons, and for ocean lovers.
Library Media Connection (October 2007)
This story is a variant of the "Three Little Pigs," and it works wonderfully.
Connections
- If you enjoyed this fractured fairy tale, you may enjoy these other versions of The Three Pigs, where the characters are also reimagined as other creatures:
McNamara, Margaret & Mark Fearing. The Three Little Aliens and the Big Bad Robot. ISBN 9780375866890
Kimmel, Eric A. The Three Little Tamales. Ill. by Valeria Docampo. ISBN 9780761455196
Lowell, Susan. The Three Little Javelinas. Ill. by Jim Harris. ISBN 9780873585422
- Story Elements Enrichment: Create a Venn diagram to compare and contrast this version of the tale to the traditional tale. Which elements of the story remained the same? Which elements changed for this underwater setting?
- Storytelling Enrichment: Have students practice storytelling by retelling this story, encouraging the use of expression and props.
- Writing Enrichment: Rewrite your own version of this classic tale. What kind of animals will your characters be? What kinds of houses will they build? How will you change the well-known, repeated question and answer responses to match your new characters and setting?
No comments:
Post a Comment