Wednesday, July 19, 2023

Turtle in Paradise: The Graphic Novel by Jennifer L. Holm & Savanna Ganucheau

 A cartoon of a child with a suitcase and a cat

Description automatically generated

Holm, Jennifer L. & Ganucheau, Savanna. 2021. Turtle in Paradise: The Graphic Novel. New York, NY: RH Graphic. ISBN 9780593126318


Summary

In June of 1935, a young girl named Turtle is sent from New Jersey to sunny Key West, Florida to stay with her aunt and cousins, after her mother gets a housekeeping job for someone who will not allow kids to be around. In the midst of the Great Depression, Turtle doesn’t find Key West to be the paradise her mom described. Turtle finds Key West to be an unusual place between all the odd nicknames, adventures with her cousin Beans and the Diaper Gang, and the discovery of a grandmother she didn’t know she had. Persistent and curious Turtle finds a clue to possible buried treasure at her grandmother’s house, which leads to the Diaper Gang getting stranded on an island during the Labor Day Hurricane. When her mother’s plans for the family with salesman Archie fall through, Turtle realizes she has already become a part of this cooky Key West family and that maybe it is a paradise after all.



Critical Analysis


While Turtle in Paradise didn’t focus on a certain event as much as a particular time period in American history, it does give a view of what life was like in Key West during the Great Depression. Jennifer L. Holm gives readers a spectacular author’s note at the end of the book, complete with black and white photographs from the 1930s. In it we learn that this story is inspired by Holm’s great-grandmother who emigrated from the Bahamas to Key West. She shares how, due to the hardships during the Great Depression, it was not uncommon for children to be left with relatives while adults went to find work. This was the case for Turtle and her mother, so this information adds authenticity to the story. Additionally, the references throughout the book to Little Orphan Annie and Shirley Temple reflected the entertainment of the times. The hurricane in the story was indeed based on a real storm from September 2, 1935 that became known as the Labor Day Hurricane. The illustrator also explains all the historic location research she did looking for photographic evidence to make sure her drawings were authentic – even going so far as to research the type of sponges that used to be harvested in Key West. Ganucheau used a map of 1930s Key West to piece together Turtle’s steps through town as well.


Through most of the book, Turtle and the Diaper Gang spend their days entertaining themselves while babysitting. Their everyday pranks and adventures will be very relatable to kids, and the colored graphics (especially of the naughty tick-tocking prank and the nickel-in-the-cup trick) will delight young readers. Turtle’s determination and intelligence really comes to light when dealing with her grandmother. Instead of giving up when Nana Philly knocks over the food she makes her, Turtle shows that instead of retreating into her own shell, she can hold her ground. The theme of Turtle’s resilience in the face of hardships parallels to the people of Key West, who must do the same during this depression.


Names and nicknames are big in this story, and just as turtle discusses with Uncle Vernon, Turtle’s name matches her personality in ways. Her mother says she has a hard shell, but her uncle tells her that while turtles may look tough, they have a soft underbelly. We later learn that Turtle’s soft underbelly is her mother and Turtle comes out of her shell to become a part of this Conch family. 


The brightly colored and pastel graphics set the tropical mood of sunny Key West, Florida perfectly and will be a major draw for children. The graphic adaptation adds to the humor and understanding of the children’s antics. Turtle in Paradise has the potential to turn some graphic novel lovers into fans of the historical fiction genre as well.



Awards & Reviews


This is a graphic novel adaptation of Holm's 2011 Newbery Honor Book of the same title.


Horn Book Magazine (September/October, 2021)

Holm's novel lends itself easily to a graphic format: its short chapters translate well into paneled illustrations, and the great bits of fun in the novel now get full-color treatment. …The titular paradise is not always sunny, but all visual efforts reinforce the brightness and buoyancy of this idiosyncratic place. 


Kirkus Reviews (March 15, 2021)

This graphic-novel adaptation of Holm’s acclaimed 2010 novel is perfectly suited to conveying the vibrant local color of Key West as well as the comic pace of Turtle’s adventures with the Diaper Gang. …A lively adaptation certain to entertain readers old and new. 


School Library Journal starred (June 1, 2021)

Holm's classic summer novel, full of pranks, peril, mystery, and discovery, gets a beautiful graphic novel treatment that if anything improves upon the original. … Adventure, friendship, and unforgettable characters make for a perfect tale. 



Connections


  • Read the novel version of Turtle in Paradise that this book is based on. How do the two versions compare? Do you gain different perspectives from Turtle?

  • Create your own graphic novel story in Savanna Ganucheau’s style depicting a short story of mischief or adventures you have gotten into with family and friends.

  • Have groups of students perform readers theatre skits of this book. The different groups could focus on different chapters or on different adventures Turtle goes on.

  • Turtle and Uncle Vernon discuss how Turtle has characteristics of the animal that shares her name. Have students research animals to determine which they are most like and why.

  • Return to Turtle’s world through the eyes of her cousin Beans in Jennifer L. Holm’s Full of Beans. ISBN 9780553510362



No comments:

Post a Comment